Jan 01, 2024 Leave a message

Pipe vs Tube: Sizing, Manufacturing, and Application Differences

Sizing: The First Difference

The most fundamental difference between pipe and tube is how they are specified. Pipe is specified by nominal pipe size (NPS) and schedule, for example NPS 6 Schedule 40. The nominal size is a label, not an actual dimension, and the outside diameter is fixed for each NPS while the wall thickness varies with the schedule. Tube is specified by the exact outside diameter and wall thickness, for example 60.3 mm OD by 3.2 mm wall, and the stated dimensions are the actual dimensions. This is why a pipe and a tube of similar appearance cannot be interchanged without re-engineering the connection.

Shape and Cross-Section

Pipe is always round, because round is the efficient shape for internal pressure and for the fittings and flanges of the piping system. Tube is available in round, square, rectangular, and other shapes. The square and rectangular hollow sections are structural products, used for columns, frames, and architectural steelwork, and the round tube serves mechanical and precision applications as well as fluid service. The shape determines the section properties, so the designer selects the shape from the load and the connection details.

Manufacturing Processes

Both pipe and tube are made by the same fundamental routes, with the process chosen from the size and the required quality. Seamless products are made by heating a solid billet and piercing it into a hollow shell, which is then rolled or drawn to size; there is no weld seam. Welded products are formed from strip or plate and closed by electric resistance welding, submerged arc welding, or another fusion process. Cold drawing is used for both pipe and tube when tight tolerances and a smooth surface are required, and it is common for precision tube. Extrusion is used for some non-ferrous and special products, but it is not the standard route for carbon steel pipe; the common description of pipe as extruded is a misconception.

Applications

Pipe is designed for the conveyance of fluids and gases under pressure: water, oil, gas, steam, and chemicals, in plumbing, pipelines, and process plants. Its pressure rating is derived from the dimensions, the grade, and the code. Tube serves three broad duties: structural, as hollow sections in buildings, bridges, and vehicles; mechanical, as machined parts such as shafts, cylinders, and rollers; and precision fluid, as hydraulic and instrumentation lines. A product that looks like a pipe may be specified as tube when it is used as a structural member, and the standard follows the application.

Strength, Cost, and Standards

The strength and cost of a product are set by the grade, the dimensions, the process, and the testing, not by whether it is called pipe or tube. A seamless pipe for high pressure costs more than a welded tube of the same size because of the process and the testing, and a precision-drawn tube costs more than a standard pipe for the same reason. The governing standards reflect the application: pipe standards such as A106, A53, and API 5L define pressure requirements, while tube standards such as A500 for structural tubing and A519 for mechanical tubing define the properties for structural and mechanical duty. The specification, not the name, decides the price and the performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between pipe and tube?

Pipe is sized by nominal size and schedule, is round, and is used for fluid conveyance under pressure. Tube is sized by exact OD and wall, comes in many shapes, and is used for structural, mechanical, and precision service.

Q: Is pipe always round?

Yes. Pipe is round because round is the efficient shape for pressure containment and for piping connections. Tube can be round, square, or rectangular.

Q: How is pipe made?

By the seamless route, piercing a solid billet, or by the welded route, forming strip and closing the seam by ERW or SAW. Cold drawing is used for precision products. Extrusion is not the standard route for carbon steel pipe.

Q: Is pipe stronger than tube?

Not inherently. Strength is set by the grade, dimensions, and process. A welded tube can be stronger than a seamless pipe of the same size, depending on the specification.

Q: Can a tube be used as pipe?

Only if it meets the requirements of the pipe standard for the service, including the pressure rating, testing, and code acceptance. The application standard governs.

Q: Why is a pipe more expensive than a tube sometimes?

Because of the process and testing, not the name. Seamless pressure pipe costs more than welded structural tube, while precision-drawn tube can cost more than standard pipe.

Send Inquiry