Sep 23, 2025 Leave a message

API 5L PSL1 vs PSL2 and ASTM A106 Seamless Steel Pipe Selection Guide

Buyers who compare API 5L PSL1, API 5L PSL2 and ASTM A106 seamless steel pipe soon find that the three documents look similar yet serve different purposes. API 5L is a line pipe specification written for pipelines that transport oil, gas and water; ASTM A106 is a high-temperature service specification written for steam, boiler and process piping. Knowing where the requirements diverge prevents over-specification, avoids rejected shipments and keeps project cost under control.

Scope of Each Specification

API 5L covers seamless and welded pipe in two product specification levels. PSL1 states the basic requirements that let a mill ship pipe with a minimum testing burden, while PSL2 keeps the same dimensional framework and adds tighter chemistry, mandatory tensile testing of the finished pipe, Charpy V-notch impact testing and non-destructive examination of the pipe body and the weld seam.

ASTM A106 covers seamless carbon steel pipe for high-temperature service in grades A, B and C, with Grade B accounting for the great majority of tonnage. Dimensions follow ASME B36.10M, so an NPS 6 Schedule 40 A106 pipe has the same outside diameter and wall thickness as the API 5L equivalent, which is exactly why the two specifications are so often confused.

API 5L PSL1: lowest test burden, widest mill availability, best for low-pressure gathering and utility lines.

API 5L PSL2: controlled chemistry, certified impact toughness and NDT records, required for critical transmission lines.

ASTM A106: elevated-temperature service, grades A, B and C, supplied hot finished or cold drawn.

Chemical Composition Comparison

The table below lists the principal limits for the most common grade in each specification, expressed in weight percent.

Element ASTM A106 Gr B API 5L Gr B PSL1 API 5L Gr B PSL2
Carbon, max 0.30 0.28 0.24
Manganese 0.29 to 1.06 1.20 max 1.40 max
Phosphorus, max 0.035 0.030 0.030
Sulfur, max 0.035 0.030 0.030
Silicon, min 0.10 not specified not specified
Weldability control not specified not specified CE 0.43 max, Pcm 0.25 max

Two differences matter in daily practice. First, A106 Grade B sets a minimum silicon content because the steel is intended for hot service, while API 5L does not. Second, only PSL2 applies a carbon equivalent or Pcm limit to the heat analysis, which is what allows a pipeline operator to qualify welding procedures with confidence before construction begins. A106 Grade A and Grade C move the carbon ceiling to 0.25 and 0.35 respectively, with matching changes to the manganese range.

Mechanical Properties and Test Requirements

Property ASTM A106 Gr B API 5L Gr B API 5L X42
Yield strength, min 240 MPa (35 ksi) 241 MPa (35 ksi) 290 MPa (42 ksi)
Tensile strength, min 415 MPa (60 ksi) 414 MPa (60 ksi) 414 MPa (60 ksi)
Yield strength, max not specified PSL2 only PSL2 only
Charpy impact test not standard PSL2 only PSL2 only
Non-destructive examination hydrostatic test PSL2 adds pipe body and seam NDT PSL2 adds pipe body and seam NDT

Impact testing on PSL2 pipe is carried out on the pipe body and, for welded product, on the weld and heat-affected zone at a temperature agreed in the purchase order, commonly 0 °C or lower. PSL1 pipe carries no impact obligation unless the buyer adds a supplementary requirement. ASTM A106 requires a hydrostatic test plus tensile and flattening or bend tests, and leaves impact testing to the order. This single difference explains much of the price gap between the two product specification levels.

Manufacturing Route and Heat Treatment

All three products are made by the seamless route: a steel billet is heated to roughly 1200 °C, pierced on a rotary piercer, then rolled on a plug mill, mandrel mill or continuous mill to the required wall, followed by sizing, straightening and cutting. Cold-drawn pipe is produced from hot-rolled hollows by drawing through a die over a mandrel, giving the tight tolerance and smooth bore needed for instrumentation and heat exchanger service.

Hot-finished A106 pipe may be supplied as rolled, but cold-drawn A106 must receive a normalizing or annealing treatment. API 5L PSL2 pipe for critical service is frequently ordered normalized or, at heavier walls, quenched and tempered so that the impact requirement is met at low temperature.

Selection Criteria for Buyers

Design temperature above 400 °C, or steam and process duty: specify ASTM A106 Grade B and confirm the allowable stress in ASME B31.1 or B31.3.

Buried pipeline moving oil, gas or water at ambient temperature: specify API 5L and choose PSL1 or PSL2 from the design factor and the welding procedure qualification.

Low-temperature exposure or sour-adjacent service: choose PSL2 and state the Charpy test temperature and absorbed energy in the purchase order.

Site bending, threading or welding: keep carbon equivalent at or below 0.43 and confirm the mill certificate shows heat numbers traceable to the test reports.

Surface protection: three-layer polyethylene or fusion-bonded epoxy for buried lines, and bare or varnished finish for above-ground high-temperature lines.

FAQ

Q: Can API 5L pipe be substituted for ASTM A106 Grade B?
Not automatically. The chemistries and minimum strengths are close, but A106 carries elevated-temperature design allowables that API 5L pipe does not. Substitution needs written approval from the design engineer.

Q: What is the single biggest difference between PSL1 and PSL2?
Testing and chemistry control. PSL2 adds a carbon equivalent limit, mandatory impact testing and non-destructive examination of the pipe body and seam, which PSL1 does not require.

Q: Is PSL2 pipe impact tested below zero?
It is tested at the temperature written into the purchase order. Common values are 0 °C, minus 10 °C and minus 20 °C for cold-climate projects, with the required absorbed energy stated per specimen.

Q: Which grade suits a steam header?
A106 Grade B is the usual choice within its allowable stress limits. For higher steam parameters the material moves to alloy grades such as A335 P11 or A335 P22.

Q: Are the dimensions different between the two standards?
No. Seamless pipe in both specifications follows ASME B36.10M, so outside diameter and wall thickness match for the same nominal size and schedule.

Q: What documents should arrive with the shipment?
A mill test certificate with heat analysis, tensile results, impact results where applicable, hydrostatic test record, NDT report for PSL2, and permanent markings that tie each length back to its heat number.

Send Inquiry