- Quality and Yield Strength
Consider yield strength. Regardless of grade, A500 material has a higher yield strength than A53 pipe. While A53 was once the standard specification for round pipes, specifying A53 for columns or supports in buildings results in thicker and larger sections than the stronger A500. Structures designed using the A500 require lighter steel; the cost savings are clear.
Additionally, Grade B steel has been replaced by Grade C steel (approximately 10% higher yield strength) as the most commonly used grade for A500 HSS, with no cost impact. (Please note that the 15th edition of the AISC Construction Manual, due to be published in 2017, will reflect this in the member capacity tables). This is a good incentive to use the highest quality steel pipe.
- Designation
A53 pipe designation is the nominal pipe diameter in inches plus one of three predetermined wall thicknesses. This size is used because A53 piping is designed to carry pressurized steam, air or water and must be used with standardized fittings and valves.
A500 pipe does not have this need, so it can be specified with greater accuracy and correspondingly higher efficiency. For A500 round pipe, outside diameter and wall thickness are in inches to three decimal places. When manufacturing architectural columns from A500 round tubing, HSS8.625×0.322 can be specified with an outside diameter (OD) tolerance of +/-0.75% and a wall thickness tolerance of +/-10%. An 8-inch standard tube equivalent to A53 has an outside diameter tolerance of +/-1% and a wall thickness tolerance of -12.5%. Therefore, A500 round tubes have better/lower OD and wall tolerances. Another word of advice: A53 tubing is only available in 21' and 42' lengths. A500 round pipe is produced in lengths ranging from 20 feet to 75 feet.

- Tolerance
As you can see, the tolerances for A500 are tighter than those for A53 tubing. You will have greater confidence when selecting section dimensions for your structural design because A500 manufacturers are also required to adhere to the straightness tolerances specified in A500 so that you not only obtain the section dimensions but also the necessary straightness. For A53, the straightness of the pipe is not specified in the standard.
- Both inside and outside
So far, we have mainly introduced the structural characteristics of these two types of pipes, but the conditions on the outside of the pipe are equally important. Because A53 pipe is produced to carry pressurized steam, water, or gas, manufacturers must hydrostatically test their product to ensure it can withstand the pressure when in use. If you are using A53 piping for a structural application, you may need to pay for testing that is not required for your application.

Additionally, when you use A53 pipe, you pay part of the cost for the sealant the manufacturer uses to coat the outside of the pipe. In order to weld these pipes, the fabricator must remove the sealant you paid for, which is an unnecessary cost and extra step in the fabrication process. The exposed surface of the A500 tube is also easier to paint.
The internal and external differences between A53 and A500 pipes make it clear: the two pipes are by no means synonymous. The A500 is the obvious choice for a wide range of structures including building columns, supports, trusses, space frames and towers.





