Mar 12, 2025 Leave a message

ASTM A500 Grade B, C and D Square Tube: Properties Compared

What ASTM A500 Square Tube Covers

ASTM A500 is the standard specification for cold formed welded and seamless carbon steel structural tubing in round, square and rectangular shapes. Grades B, C and D are the three structural grades most often ordered as square tube. All three are cold formed from hot rolled coil, welded along a longitudinal seam and then sized after welding, which gives square and rectangular hollow sections their flat faces and controlled corner radii. A500 tube is a structural member rather than a pressure pipe, and it is normally supplied in lengths of 6 m or 12 m.

Grade Comparison: Strength and Properties

Property A500 Grade B A500 Grade C A500 Grade D
Tensile strength, min 400 MPa, 58 ksi 427 MPa, 62 ksi 427 MPa, 62 ksi
Yield strength, min 290 MPa, 42 ksi 317 MPa, 46 ksi 345 MPa, 50 ksi
Typical use General structural framing Loaded framing and equipment supports Highly loaded columns and booms

The three grades are separated mainly by guaranteed minimum yield strength and by the chemistry needed to reach it. Grade B is the general purpose grade with the lowest minimum yield of 290 MPa. Grade C raises the minimum yield to 317 MPa. Grade D reaches 345 MPa, the highest of the three, and is produced with tighter chemistry control and often with micro-alloying additions. If a design has been calculated on Grade B and the tube is supplied in Grade D, the section is not weaker. If a design assumes Grade D and the material supplied is Grade B, the member is seriously under strength, which is why grade verification matters on structural jobs.

Elongation requirements are specified for each grade in the standard and are set at a ductile minimum which is slightly lower as strength rises, so Grade B is the most forgiving grade for severe forming. Certificates should always show tensile, yield and elongation results for the lot that was supplied.

Chemistry and the Corrosion Question

A commonly repeated claim is that a higher carbon content gives better corrosion resistance. That is not correct for carbon steel. Increasing carbon and manganese raises strength, but it does not improve resistance to atmospheric or water corrosion, and higher carbon levels reduce weldability and toughness. All three A500 grades are carbon steels and all three rust at a comparable rate under the same exposure.

Corrosion protection is therefore a coating decision rather than a grade decision. Square tube for outdoor or wet service is normally hot dip galvanized to GB/T 13912 or ASTM A153, painted, or given a zinc rich primer, and the coating system determines service life. Where a specification demands a long unpainted life, a weathering steel or a stainless hollow section should be considered instead of simply moving to a higher A500 grade.

Forming, Welding and Fabrication

A500 square tube is cold formed, so the corner radii are produced by the forming rolls and the material has some work hardening in the corners before it leaves the mill. Higher strength grades have less remaining ductility, which shows up in two ways: more springback during bending, and a greater risk of cracking when the tube is bent to a tight radius. Grade B is the easiest grade to bend, notch and flatten, while Grade C and especially Grade D should be bent to generous radii with the bend direction checked against the weld location.

Welding is straightforward with normal carbon steel procedures. The longitudinal seam is a high frequency welded seam and it accepts filler welds without difficulty. Where square tube is welded into frames, keep welds away from the corner radius, and allow for slightly different heat input on Grade D sections to avoid excessive hardening in the heat affected zone.

Ordering Guidance and Pitfalls

State the standard, grade, shape, outside dimensions, wall thickness, length and quantity, and quote the tolerances for wall and squareness that the project needs, because A500 tolerances are generous compared with machined tube.

Do not specify A500 for pressure service. If the section will contain fluid under pressure, a pipe specification such as A53 or A106 is required.

Check the corner radius against the wall thickness, since thin wall sections with large radii behave differently in bending.

Agree the coating before fabrication, because galvanizing after welding is more reliable than coating a finished frame.

Another common pitfall is mixing grades inside one frame. Where a drawing calls for Grade D in the columns and Grade B in the bracing, keep the materials separated and marked, because a Grade B length installed in a Grade D position is very difficult to detect after the frame is welded.

FAQ

Q: What is the difference between A500 Grade B, C and D?
They are three structural grades of the same cold formed tubing specification separated by guaranteed minimum yield strength: 290 MPa for Grade B, 317 MPa for Grade C and 345 MPa for Grade D.

Q: Does higher carbon in A500 square tube improve corrosion resistance?
No. All three grades are carbon steel and rust at a comparable rate. Corrosion resistance comes from galvanizing, painting or selecting a different material family such as stainless steel.

Q: Which grade should be used for cold bending?
Grade B forms most easily because it has the lowest strength and the greatest remaining ductility. Grade C and Grade D need larger bend radii and more allowance for springback.

Q: Can A500 square tube be used for pressure applications?
No. A500 is a structural tubing specification. Fluid under pressure requires a pipe specification such as ASTM A53 or A106 with the corresponding pressure testing.

Q: What lengths is A500 square tube supplied in?
Square and rectangular A500 tube is normally supplied in random or fixed lengths of 6 m or 12 m. Other lengths can be produced by agreement with the mill.

Q: Where is the weld seam positioned on a square tube?
The mill normally places the longitudinal seam on a flat face. For bending and for appearance, the seam position should be stated on the order so that it is not placed on the tension side of a bend.

Send Inquiry