What ASTM A179 and A214 Cover
ASTM A179 and A214 are both carbon steel tube specifications written for heat transfer equipment, but they are produced by different routes and are used in different parts of the same exchanger. A179 covers seamless cold drawn low carbon steel tubes for heat exchangers, condensers and similar heat transfer apparatus. A214 covers electric resistance welded carbon steel tubes for heat exchangers and condensers. ASME adopts both as SA-179 and SA-214, so the two designations describe identical requirements in each case.
A common misconception is that one standard is simply a narrower version of the other. The real distinction is the manufacturing route. A179 is seamless and cold drawn, while A214 is welded from strip and is normally supplied as welded or as welded and drawn. That difference drives pressure capability, available sizes and cost.
Chemistry and Mechanical Requirements
| Item | ASTM A179, ASME SA-179 | ASTM A214, ASME SA-214 |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing route | Seamless, cold drawn | Electric resistance welded |
| Carbon, % | 0.06 to 0.18 | 0.18 max |
| Manganese, % | 0.27 to 0.63 | 0.70 max |
| Phosphorus, % max | 0.035 | 0.035 |
| Sulfur, % max | 0.035 | 0.035 |
| Tensile strength, min | 325 MPa | 415 MPa |
| Yield strength, min | 180 MPa | 240 MPa |
| Hardness, max | 72 HRB | 72 HRB |
The controlled carbon range of A179 keeps the tube soft and ductile, which is what allows it to be rolled into a tube sheet and bent into U shapes without cracking. A214 accepts slightly more carbon and manganese and therefore reaches a higher strength level, which suits longer and more heavily loaded exchangers where a welded tube is permitted. Both specifications require the tube to be suitable for bending, flaring and similar forming operations, and both are supplied in the annealed condition.
Tubes are ordered by outside diameter and wall thickness, and the standard sizes for both specifications are small, typically 12.7 mm to 76.2 mm outside diameter with walls from about 0.9 mm to 3.4 mm. Other sizes are available by agreement.
Related ASME Specifications in the Same Family
Heat exchanger projects rarely use A179 or A214 alone, so it helps to know the neighbouring specifications. SA-210 covers seamless medium carbon steel boiler and superheater tubes in Grade A-1 and Grade C. Grade A-1 is a carbon manganese steel and Grade C is a carbon manganese silicon steel with higher strength; both grades require a minimum tensile strength of 485 MPa and a minimum yield of 275 MPa, which is well above the A179 level.
SA-266 covers carbon steel forgings for pressure vessel components, where Grade 2 is the general purpose grade and Grade 4 is the higher strength grade used for heavier parts. SA-216 covers carbon steel castings for valves, flanges and fittings in Grades WCA, WCB and WCC, with WCA for the lowest strength and temperature duty, WCB as the general purpose grade and WCC for higher strength and impact requirements. In short, A179, A214 and A210 cover the tubes, while A266 and A216 cover the forged and cast pressure retaining parts around them, and a purchase specification should never confuse the two groups.
Selection and Ordering Guidance
Choose A179 when the exchanger is of seamless construction, when the tubes must be expanded into a tube sheet, or when the design does not permit a longitudinal weld.
Choose A214 when a welded tube is acceptable, when longer lengths are useful and when the higher strength of the welded product suits the design.
State the standard, outside diameter, wall thickness, length, quantity and whether the tubes are straight lengths or U bends.
Ask for the eddy current or hydrostatic test required by the specification, the tensile data and the hardness result, because forming behaviour depends on hardness.
Inspection Points and Common Pitfalls
The first trap is treating A179 and A214 as freely interchangeable. They are not, because A214 contains a longitudinal weld and its use against a specification written for seamless tube is a deviation that should be agreed with the designer. The second trap is ignoring hardness: a tube that meets tensile strength but exceeds the hardness limit will crack when it is rolled and expanded. The third trap is surface condition, since cold drawn tubes need a clean scale free surface for the tube sheet joint and welded tubes need inner weld flash controlled if they are to be drawn. Finally, the bending radius should be checked against the wall thickness, because thin wall tubes buckle when the bend is too tight.
FAQ
Q: What is the difference between SA 179 and SA 214?
SA 179 is a seamless cold drawn low carbon tube for heat exchangers and condensers, while SA 214 is an electric resistance welded carbon steel tube for the same service. The difference is the manufacturing route and the resulting strength level.
Q: Are A179 and A214 interchangeable?
Only where the specification permits it. A214 has higher strength but contains a longitudinal weld, so it is not a direct substitute for a seamless A179 tube when seamless construction is specified.
Q: What is A179 tube used for?
Shell and tube heat exchangers, condensers, feedwater heaters and similar heat transfer equipment that operate at moderate temperature and pressure.
Q: What is SA 210 material?
SA 210 is the seamless medium carbon steel boiler and superheater tube specification in Grades A-1 and C, with a higher minimum strength than A179 and intended for higher pressure and temperature service.
Q: What is SA 266 used for?
SA 266 covers carbon steel forgings for pressure vessel components such as tube sheets, covers and fittings, with Grade 2 for general duty and Grade 4 for higher strength parts.
Q: What is SA 216 material?
SA 216 covers carbon steel castings for pressure containing parts such as valves, flanges and fittings in Grades WCA, WCB and WCC, with WCC offering the higher strength and impact performance.





